Cleveland-Cliffs Makes the Steel Detroit Can't Buy Anywhere Else. We Collect 45%.
CORE · VALUE PICKSuggested portfolio size — Min $15K · Ideal $15K+
⏱ The 30-second version
- The trade: sell the Cleveland-Cliffs (CLF) $11 PUT expiring September 25. Collect about $15 to $20 cash per contract today.
- Your return: yours the moment you sell... about 45% annualized at your floor on the $1,100 you set aside, up to 60% at the live ask.
- The cushion: CLF trades near $11.92, so the stock has about 7.7% of room before our strike even comes into play.
- If assigned: you buy CLF at $11, and with the premium your real cost is about $10.85, roughly 16% under my estimate of the business value.
Want it laid out? Skip to the alert box. Want the why? Keep reading.
The company
Cleveland-Cliffs is American steel, and it owns more of its own chain than almost anyone else in the business. It mines the iron ore, processes the scrap, makes the steel, finishes it, and runs the stamping, tooling and tubing operations on the back end. Iron ore goes in one door and a finished automotive part comes out the other.
That automotive piece is the part worth understanding. About 30% of 2025 sales went straight to carmakers, with another 29% to infrastructure and manufacturing. Steel for the outside panel of a car is not rebar. The strength, the surface finish, the corrosion resistance, the way it has to bend without cracking... all of it has to be consistent, and that lets automotive steel price above commodity grades.
Why I'm interested at $11
Let me be plain: this is a cyclical recovery story, not a wonderful business. It has been through a weak stretch and it is still losing money on a GAAP basis.
But the direction has turned. Second-quarter revenue rose from $4.9 billion to $5.2 billion. Adjusted EBITDA jumped from $95 million to $286 million. Operating cash flow came in at $230 million. The net loss was still $134 million, so nobody should pretend this is fixed... it is improving.
There's a structural tailwind underneath it too. Cliffs has locked in multi-year fixed-price contracts with major automotive customers, and US steel and auto tariffs favor steel made here. Management has been cutting costs and shutting down the operations that weren't earning their keep.
And there's a piece most people miss entirely. Cliffs makes specialized electrical steel, the kind that goes into EV motors and power transformers. That's not an old-blast-furnace story. That's grid buildout and electrification, and it's sitting inside a company the market still prices as pure commodity steel.
My estimate of business value is about $13 a share. At $11.92 today that's only about a 9% margin of safety, which is not enough for me to simply go buy the stock. But our $11 strike, minus the premium, puts our real cost at $10.85, and that's about 16% under the number. That gap is the whole reason this trade interests me and the stock doesn't.
Why we'd be glad to own it at $11
- Real cost of about $10.85, roughly 16% under my $13 estimate of business value
- Adjusted EBITDA tripled quarter over quarter, $95M to $286M
- Multi-year fixed-price automotive contracts, plus tariffs that favor domestic steel
- Electrical steel for EV motors and transformers that the market isn't paying for
- Earnings not until October 19... nothing due inside our window
Risks at a glance
Somewhere out there is a fund manager sitting on steel exposure who wants a floor under it into the end of the quarter, and he'll pay us for that floor. We're glad to take the other side. Either the escrow comes home with our $15-plus banked from day one, or we own a business I value at $13 for a real cost of $10.85 and start selling Rebound CALLs on it.
- About $7.7 billion of long-term debt and heavy sustaining capex. This is the reason my margin of safety isn't wider, and it's the thing to watch if steel prices roll over again.
- Still unprofitable on a GAAP basis. The turn is real but it is not finished.
- This is the most volatile name on the list. If the market has a bad week, CLF has a worse one.
- Open interest at this strike is 394 contracts, lighter than most of our picks. Use a limit, not a market order.
Cash Flow Options Alert — Pick #1
Here's what that line means, in plain words:
- Ticker
- CLF (Cleveland-Cliffs Inc.)
- Contract
- September 25, 2026 — $11 PUT
- Limit price
- aim for $0.20 — never go below $0.15
- Current Stock Price
- ~$11.92
- Days to expiration
- 11
- Premium collected
- ~$15 to $20 per contract
- Cash to secure it
- $1,100 per contract
- Annualized return
- about 45% at your floor — up to 60% if you catch the ideal fill
- If assigned
- You buy the stock at $11 a share, real cost about $10.85, then we sell Rebound CALLs for more cash flow